
These hotels sit inside the grid of side streets where most Broadway houses are. From here the majority of theaters are a short walk, which matters most on a two-show day.
Hotel Edison, Civilian Hotel, The Belvedere Hotel

Staying in the 50s puts you right by the northern theaters (Studio 54, the Broadway, Neil Simon, August Wilson, Gershwin) and a little farther from the 42nd–44th Street houses.
Ameritania at Times Square

Hotels below and west of Times Square tend to be newer or more themed. You trade a longer walk to the 47th–52nd Street theaters for more choice in room style.
Pod Times Square, Margaritaville Resort Times Square, Arlo Midtown