The Whole Night

Home / Hotels / 38th–42nd Streets

South and west: West 38th–42nd Streets

Hotels below and west of Times Square tend to be newer or more themed. You trade a longer walk to the 47th–52nd Street theaters for more choice in room style.

Street scene near the hotels in this area
Photo: 0x010C, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Pod Times Square

400 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036 · Hell's Kitchen / far west 42nd St

A micro-room hotel west of Ninth Avenue with small, efficient rooms, including bunk-bed pods.

Best for budget travelers and friends happy to share a small room.

Watch out: Rooms are tiny (the bunk pod is listed at 115 sq ft), and it sits west of Ninth Avenue, so it is a longer walk to the theaters east of Broadway.

Walk to the theaters: 5–17 min to most houses (median 10 min). Closest: Al Hirschfeld Theatre (5 min), St. James Theatre (7 min), Broadhurst Theatre (7 min), John Golden Theatre (7 min).

Lowest nightly rates sampled for Pod Times Square
Sample stay (Fri–Sun, 2 adults)Lowest nightly rateWhat the site says is includedSource
Dec 4, 2026 – Dec 6, 2026$602Including taxes and feesHotel booking page for Pod Times Square, Dec 4, 2026
Dec 11, 2026 – Dec 13, 2026$553Including taxes and feesHotel booking page for Pod Times Square, Dec 11, 2026
Jan 15, 2027 – Jan 17, 2027$163Including taxes and feesHotel booking page for Pod Times Square, Jan 15, 2027
Jan 22, 2027 – Jan 24, 2027$143Including taxes and feesHotel booking page for Pod Times Square, Jan 22, 2027
Feb 12, 2027 – Feb 14, 2027$203Including taxes and feesHotel booking page for Pod Times Square, Feb 12, 2027
Mar 5, 2027 – Mar 7, 2027$193Including taxes and feesHotel booking page for Pod Times Square, Mar 5, 2027

Check rates for your dates Hotel website

Arlo Midtown

351 West 38th Street, New York, NY 10018 · Garment District, south of the theater blocks

A design-led hotel with small rooms, a few blocks south of Times Square.

Best for younger travelers and couples who want a lively hotel and don't mind a walk.

Watch out: It is south of the theater blocks, so most theaters are a longer walk than from the hotels on 47th–48th Streets; check-in age is 21 per its booking page, and the cheapest rate is non-refundable.

Walk to the theaters: 7–21 min to most houses (median 12 min). Closest: Nederlander Theatre (7 min), New Amsterdam Theatre (8 min), Todd Haimes Theatre (8 min), St. James Theatre (9 min).

Lowest nightly rates sampled for Arlo Midtown
Sample stay (Fri–Sun, 2 adults)Lowest nightly rateWhat the site says is includedSource
Dec 4, 2026 – Dec 6, 2026$900Including the urban fee, excluding taxesHotel booking page for Arlo Midtown, Dec 4, 2026
Dec 11, 2026 – Dec 13, 2026$842Including the urban fee, excluding taxesHotel booking page for Arlo Midtown, Dec 11, 2026
Jan 15, 2027 – Jan 17, 2027$183Including the urban fee, excluding taxesHotel booking page for Arlo Midtown, Jan 15, 2027
Jan 22, 2027 – Jan 24, 2027$147Including the urban fee, excluding taxesHotel booking page for Arlo Midtown, Jan 22, 2027
Feb 12, 2027 – Feb 14, 2027$306Including the urban fee, excluding taxesHotel booking page for Arlo Midtown, Feb 12, 2027
Mar 5, 2027 – Mar 7, 2027$180Including the urban fee, excluding taxesHotel booking page for Arlo Midtown, Mar 5, 2027

Check rates for your dates Hotel website

Margaritaville Resort Times Square

560 Seventh Avenue, New York, NY 10018 · Times Square south / Garment District

A large resort-style hotel on Seventh Avenue at 40th Street with a rooftop and beach-themed decor.

Best for families and groups who want a big, cheerful hotel with lots of on-site options.

Watch out: The theme is loud and touristy, and our sampled rates were the highest in this guide outside December.

Walk to the theaters: 1–18 min to most houses (median 7 min). Closest: Nederlander Theatre (1 min), New Amsterdam Theatre (2 min), Lyric Theatre (4 min), Todd Haimes Theatre (4 min).

Lowest nightly rates sampled for Margaritaville Resort Times Square
Sample stay (Fri–Sun, 2 adults)Lowest nightly rateWhat the site says is includedSource
Dec 4, 2026 – Dec 6, 2026$875Including fees before taxesHotel booking page for Margaritaville Resort Times Square, Dec 4, 2026
Dec 11, 2026 – Dec 13, 2026$923Including fees before taxesHotel booking page for Margaritaville Resort Times Square, Dec 11, 2026
Jan 15, 2027 – Jan 17, 2027$288Including fees before taxesHotel booking page for Margaritaville Resort Times Square, Jan 15, 2027
Jan 22, 2027 – Jan 24, 2027$277Including fees before taxesHotel booking page for Margaritaville Resort Times Square, Jan 22, 2027
Feb 12, 2027 – Feb 14, 2027$305Including fees before taxesHotel booking page for Margaritaville Resort Times Square, Feb 12, 2027
Mar 5, 2027 – Mar 7, 2027$396Including fees before taxesHotel booking page for Margaritaville Resort Times Square, Mar 5, 2027

Check rates for your dates Hotel website

Compare all hotels and walking times

Last verified: Nov 21, 2026. Sources: