The Whole Night

Home / Itineraries / Your first Broadway weekend

Your first Broadway weekend

A long-running hit, a hotel in the middle of the theater blocks, and the free library on Saturday morning.

Friday: check in and eat early

Check in at Hotel Edison. Best for first-timers who want to walk to almost any theater in a few minutes. Watch out: Its own booking page says the lowest rates shown apply to signed-in members, and the standard rooms are compact (220–225 sq ft listed). Lowest nightly rates we saw on its own site: $150–$861 (sample weekends, checked Nov 21, 2026).

Check rates

Saturday: the show

See The Great Gatsby at the Broadway Theatre. A lavish musical version of Fitzgerald's novel, heavy on Jazz Age costumes and sets. Best for couples who want a glamorous, good-looking night out. Watch out: The look is the main event; people who love the novel's darker edges may find it glossy.

Tickets: $57–$498 on Telecharge (checked Nov 21, 2026). Running time: 2 hours and 30 minutes with 1 intermission.

Get tickets

Before curtain, eat at Glass House Tavern, about 8 minutes' walk from the theater: $70 per person (Prix fixe dinner, $70 per person, served 3pm–11pm daily (for groups of 9 or fewer), per its menu.). Watch out: The prix fixe menu is short, with three entrée choices.

Sunday: one more thing

New York Public Library, Stephen A. Schwarzman Building. The Beaux-Arts flagship library at Fifth Avenue and 42nd Street, with a free treasures exhibition. Best for a free, quiet morning on a matinee day. Watch out: The Reading Room visiting hour is only 10–11am Monday–Saturday. Cost: free. The library offers free daily guided tours and a free visiting hour in the Rose Main Reading Room (10–11am, Monday–Saturday), per its site.

If that show is not for you

Rough cost per person

From about $277 per person: the cheapest published ticket, half of one night at the lowest rate we sampled, dinner and the extra. Add a second night, tax, tips and booking fees. Your dates will change the hotel rate a lot; December weekends sampled at several times the January price.

Price this for my dates

Last verified: Nov 21, 2026. Sources: